Perception and use of informal coercion in outpatient treatment: a focus group study with mental health professionals of Latin culture
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##
Abstract
Introduction. In addition to compulsion (involuntary hospitalization, seclusion, restraint, etc.), there are broader forms of coercion (persuasion, interpersonal pressure, inducement or threat), called informal or covert coercion, all of which try to improve patients adherence to treatment.
Objective. To analyse the use of covert coercion in mental health outpatients and the mental health professionals´ views on this practice comparing four countries (Spain, Italy, Mexico and Chile).
Methods. We conducted a qualitative research using four focus groups in each country with mental health professionals working in mental health centres and based on a thematic analysis approach. Sample. The total sample was made up of 98 professionals (31 psychiatrists, 25 clinical psychologists, 28 nurses, eight social workers and six other professionals).
Results. The use of informal coercion was recognized in clinical practice, but its intensity was related to professionals´ characteristics and to factors related to diagnosis, clinical course, perceived risk, insight, therapeutic relationship and organizational issues in the delivery of services. Its use was justified by effectiveness in improving adherence and, generally, in seeking benefits for the patient, but sometimes in a paternalistic way.
Discussion and conclusion. Our results match those described in the literature in terms of: 1. sociodemographic and clinical profile; 2. the reason that leads to its use (adherence); 3. ethical justification (search for patient´s benefit, trying not to impair his freedom); hence, the most intense forms (threat) were misperceived. Our professionals acknowledged the use of covert coercion in their clinical practice, justifying it on ethical and clinical grounds.
References
- Appelbaum PS. Twenty-Five Years of Law and Psychiatry. Psychiatry Services 2006; 57:18-20
- Torres F, Mayoral F, Grupo Eunomia. La utilización de medidas coercitivas en psiquiatría. Actas Esp Psiquiatr 2005; 33(5):331-338
- Monahan J, Redlich A, Swanson J, Robbins P, Appelbaum PS, Petrila J, Steadman HJ, Swartz M, Angell B, McNiel DE. Use of leverage to improve adherence to psychiatric treatment in the community. Psychiatr Serv 2005; 56: 37–44.
- Barrios Flores L. Usos de Medios Coercitivos en Psiquiatría: Retrospectiva y Propuesta de Regulación. Derecho y Salud 2003; 11: 141-163.
- Molodynski A, Rugkasa J, Burns T. Coercion and compulsion in community mental health care. British Medical Bulletin 2010; 95:105-119
- Jaeger M, Rossler W. Enhancement of outpatient treatment adherence: Patients' perceptions of coercion, fairness and effectiveness. Psychiatry Research 2010; 30: 48-53.
- Szmukler G, Appelbaum PS. Treatment pressures, leverage, coercion, and compulsion in mental health care. J Mental Health 2008; 17:233–44.
- Kallert TW, Glöckner M, Onchev G, Raboch J, Karastergiou A, Solomon Z, Magliano L, Dembinskas A, Kiejna A, Nawka P, Torres-González F, Priebe S, Kjellin L. EUNOMIA project on coercion in psychiatry: study design and preliminary data. World Psychiatry 2005; 4(3): 168-172.
- Molodynski A, Turnpenny L, Rugkasa J, Burns T, Moussaoui D and the World Association of Social Psychiatry International Working Group on Coercion. Coercion and compulsion in mental healthcare—An international perspective. Asian Journal of Psychiatry 2014; 8: 2–6
-Claassen D, Fakhoury WK, Ford R, Priebe S. Money for medication: financial incentives to improve medication adherence in assertive outreach. Psychiatr Bull 2007; 31:4–7
-Appelbaum PS, Le Melle S. Techniques used by Assertive Community Treatment (ACT). Teams to encourage adherence: Patient and Staff Perceptions. Community and Mental Health Journal 2008; 44: 459-464
-Priebe S, Sinclair J, Burton A, Marougka S, Larsen J, Firn M, Ashcroft R. Acceptability of offering financial incentives to achieve medication adherence in patients with severe mental illness: a focus group study. J Med Ethics. 2010 Aug;36(8):463-8.
-Rugkåsa J, Canvin K, Sinclair J, Sulman A, Burns T. Trust, deals and authority: community mental health professionals' experiences of influencing reluctant patients. Community Ment Health J. 2014; 50(8):886-95.
-Valenti E, Banks C, Calcedo A, Bensimon CM, Hoffman K-M, Pelto-Piri V, Jurin J, Márquez OM, Mundt AP, Rugkåsa J, Tubini J, Pribe S. Informal coerción in psychiatry. A focus group study of attitudes and experiences of mental health professionals in ten countries. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2015; 50 (8): 1297-308.
-Burton A, Marougka S, Priebe S. Do financial incentives increase treatment adherence in people with severe mental illness? A systematic review. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 2010; 19 (3): 233-242.
-Priebe S, Yeeles K, Bremner S, Lauber C, Eldridge S, Ashby D, David AS, O'Connell N, Forrest A, Burns T. Effectiveness of financial incentives to improve adherence to maintenance treatment with antipsychotics: cluster randomised controlled trial. Br Med J 2013; 347: f5847.
-Gert B, Culver CM, Clouser KD. Bioethics a systematic approach, 2ª ed. Nueva York: Oxford University Press, 2006.
-Angell B, Martinez NI, Mahoney CA, Corrigan PW. Payeeship, Financial Leverage, and the Client-Provider Relationship. Psychiatric Services 2007; 58: 365–372.
-Onwuegbuzie AJ, Dickinson WB, Leech NL, Zoran AG. A qualitative framework for collecting and analyzing data in focus group research. Int J Qual Methods 2009; 8(3):1-21.
-Braun V, Clarke, V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 2006; 3(2):77-101.
- Szmukler G. Treatment pressures, coercion and compulsion in mental health care. J Mental Health 2008; 17: 219-221.
-Burns T, Yeeles K, Molodynski A, Nightingale H, Vázquez-Montes M, Sheehan K, Linsell L. Pressures to adhere to treatment ('leverage') in English mental healthcare. British Journal of Psychiatry 2011; 199; 145-150.
-Diamond RJ. Coercion and tenacious treatment in the community: Application to the real world. En: Dennis DL, Monahan J (eds.). Coercion and Aggressive Community Treatment: A New Frontier in Mental Health Law. New York: Plenum Press, 1996: 51-72.
-McGrew JH, Wilson RG, Bond GR. An exploratory study of what clients like least about assertive community treatment. Psychiatric Services 2002; 53: 761–763.
-Angell B, Mahoney CA, Martinez NI. Promoting treatment adherence in assertive community treatment. Social Service Review 2006; 80: 485–526.
-Monahan J, Bonnie RJ, Appelbaum PS, Hyde PS, Steadman HJ, Swartz MS. Mandated Community Treatment: Beyond Outpatient Commitment. Psychiatric Services 2001; 52: 1198-2005.
-Appelbaum PS, Redlich A. Use of Leverage Over Patients’ Money to Promote Adherence to Psychiatric Treatment. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2006;194: 294–302.
-Conrad KJ, Lutz G, Matters MD, Donner L, Clark E, Lynch P. Randomized trial of psychiatric care with representative payeeship for persons with serious mental illness. Psychiatric Services 2006; 57:197–204
-Canvin K, Rugkåsa J, Sinclair J, Burns T. Leverage and other informal pressures in community psychiatry in England. Int J Law Psychiatry 2013; 36(2):100-6.
-Bonnie RJ, Monahan J. From Coercion to Contract: Reframing the Debate on Mandated Community Treatment for People with Mental Disorders. Law and Human Behavior 2005; 29, 485-503.
-Sjöstrand M, Helgesson G. Coercive treatment and autonomy in psychiatry. Bioethics 2008; 22(2): 113-20
-Watson AC, Angell B. Applying procedural justice theory to law enforcement's response to persons with mental illness. Psychiatr Serv 2007; 58, 787–793.
-Swartz MS, Swanson JW, Hannon MJ. Does fear of coercion keep people away from mental health treatment? Evidence froma survey of persons with schizophrenia and mental health professionals. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 2003; 21, 459–472.
